A leaking tank or a smell of gas comes first
If water is pooling under the tank, close the cold water valve on the pipe going into the top of it. On an electric heater, switch off its breaker at the panel. On a gas heater, turn the control knob to off or pilot. Then put towels down, move boxes off the floor and leave the tank alone. The water inside is hot enough to scald, and draining it isn't a job to rush.
If you smell gas near the heater, don't flip any switches or light anything. Leave the house and call your gas utility's emergency line from outside. Water coming from the bottom seam of the tank is an emergency call. A slow drip from a fitting on top, or from the relief valve pipe, usually isn't urgent and can wait for a booked visit. Put a pail under it and keep an eye on it until then.
No hot water usually has a simple cause
On an electric tank, the usual causes are a tripped breaker, a tripped high-limit reset, a burnt-out element or a failed thermostat. Hot water that runs out after a few minutes often means the lower element has gone, and the upper one is only heating a little at the top. On a gas tank, the cause is more often the pilot, the thermocouple that keeps it lit, or a venting fault that shuts the burner down.
You can check the breaker yourself. On a gas heater, you can also look through the small window near the burner to see whether the pilot is lit. If those are fine, call. When the tank itself is dry and sound, a new element, thermostat or thermocouple is a repair that will hold, and there's no reason to replace the whole heater for it.
Rusty water is worth a second look before anyone blames the tank. In the older brick houses of Jordan and Beamsville, the galvanized steel water pipe rusts from the inside. Run a cold tap: if the cold water is brown too, the pipe is the more likely source. That's a plumbing repair, not a new heater.
Hard water wears tanks out faster here
Niagara Region's Grimsby Water Treatment Plant supplies part of Lincoln, and the Region listed the hardness of its water at 126 mg/L on October 1, 2025. That's hard enough to leave scale. In a tank, the scale settles on the bottom as a layer of grit that the burner or lower element has to heat through. You hear it as popping or rumbling while the heater runs, and you notice it when the hot water takes longer to come back after a shower.
Once a year, draining a few litres from the valve at the bottom of the tank carries off some of the sediment. If what comes out is milky or gritty, that's scale. Inside the tank, the anode rod wears away so the steel doesn't, and it goes faster in hard water. Checking it, and replacing it while the tank is still dry, is one of the few things that makes a tank last longer. Tankless heaters need their heat exchanger descaled on a regular schedule, or they start shutting down and showing error codes.
A tank that leaks from the body can't be repaired
Once the steel inside has rusted through, no patch will last. Water at the base, rust streaks down the side or a wet pan under the heater means the tank needs replacing, whatever its age. To find out how old it is, look at the rating label on the side. Most labels give the date it was made, though sometimes it's coded into the serial number.
An older tank that has started rumbling, or needs a second part within a year, is usually worth replacing when it suits you, before it fails on a Sunday night with water on the floor. A younger tank with one failed part is usually worth fixing. Before you pay for anything, look up the manufacturer warranty for your heater. Many cover the tank for longer than people expect, and some cover parts too. Our guide on how long a water heater lasts goes through the decision in more detail.
Water at the tub and shower is limited to 49 °C
Part 7 of Ontario's Building Code limits the water coming from a shower head or into a bathtub to 49 °C. Tanks are often set hotter than that. A mixing valve near the heater blends in cold water, so the tank can stay hot while the water at the tub stays at or under the limit.
Young children and older people burn fastest, so it's worth checking. Run the bathtub on full hot for a minute and hold a kitchen thermometer in the stream. If it reads above 49 °C, turn the tank down a little, or ask us about a mixing valve on the next visit.
How a replacement or installation goes
We start with the house: how many people live there, how many bathrooms you have, whether the basement has room for a bigger tank or a wall that suits a tankless unit, and what the venting and electrical supply will allow. A new heater is sized to your household rather than copied from the old label. You get a written price for the heater, the parts and the labour, and you approve it before anything is disconnected.
Work is performed by licensed plumbers (306A Certificate of Qualification). Gas work is performed by TSSA-certified gas technicians. The old tank is drained and removed. The new one is filled and the air purged before the power or gas is turned on, and then the connections are checked for leaks with the hot taps running. Whether a job needs a permit depends on the work, and the Town's building department decides. If yours needs one, we tell you before we start.
If your heater is getting on in years or has started to rumble, you can ask for a written price now and decide in your own time.
